How to use the Holdco Payout Comparison
The tool answers one question: to get a given amount of after-tax cash out of the corporation, what does each route cost in total corporate and personal tax?
1. Enter your own income
The personal side describes you, before anything is drawn from the corporation: tax year, province, whether you are 65 or over, and any other ordinary income, interest, taxable capital gains, eligible dividends you receive personally (for example from public shares in a non-registered account), non-eligible dividends from other corporations, RRSP deduction and OAS. The province matters twice: it selects the personal rate table and the provincial dividend tax credit.
2. Enter the corporation's balances
The corporate side is the money and the tax pools behind it:
- Cash available to distribute — the hard ceiling. No route can distribute cash the corporation does not hold.
- CDA — the capital dividend account. Caps the tax-free capital dividend route.
- GRIP — the capacity to pay eligible dividends. A zero GRIP disables that route.
- RDTOH — the eligible and non-eligible refundable tax pools. They determine the dividend refund.
- PUC by class — the paid-up capital that can be returned tax-free.
- Loan owed to shareholder — caps the tax-free loan repayment route.
- Salary is deductible to the corporation — switch this off if the corporation has no taxable income for the salary deduction to offset.
3. Set the after-tax cash target
The slider and the number box set the amount you want to end up with, after personal tax. The tool then solves each route's gross extraction to reach that target. The routes are not compared at the same gross amount; they are compared at the same after-tax cash, which is the only fair basis.
4. Read the six routes
| Route | What it is |
|---|---|
| Loan repayment | Repaying money the shareholder lent the corporation. Tax-free, capped at the loan balance. |
| Return of PUC | Returning paid-up capital. Tax-free to the extent of PUC; a deemed gain can arise above ACB. |
| Capital dividend | A tax-free dividend paid out of the CDA. |
| Eligible dividend | A taxable dividend with the larger gross-up and credit, capped at GRIP. |
| Non-eligible dividend | A taxable dividend with the smaller gross-up and credit, unlimited. |
| Salary | Employment income with CPP/QPP, EI and QPIP; the corporation deducts the salary and employer payroll. |
The table's columns are gross extraction, personal tax, corporate tax net of refund, total tax, after-tax cash, average rate, marginal rate and integration difference. Total tax = personal + corporate, plus, on the salary row, the payroll you and the corporation pay (CPP or QPP, EI, QPIP). The OAS clawback is shown on its own line and is not in total tax. A negative corporate figure is a refund or a salary deduction, not cash in the shareholder's pocket.
5. Open "Show steps"
Every row has a steps view. It shows the arithmetic in the same order the engine used it: the gross extraction, the corporate tax, the net income and taxable income, the federal and provincial credits, the OAS clawback, and the after-tax cash. For salary it also shows the employee and employer payroll, the payroll credit and the corporate deduction at the province’s general rate. The steps are the audit trail; if a number looks wrong, start there.
6. Watch for "NOT AVAILABLE" and zero
The tool keeps "cannot run" strictly apart from "costs nothing". A route with no balance behind it — no GRIP, no CDA, no loan, no PUC — is greyed out with a reason and shows em dashes, not zeros. A capital dividend with a CDA is a real zero-tax route and shows a real $0. That distinction is deliberate and is tested.
A route that hits its cap shows the cap and says it cannot reach the target on its own. The table solves each route independently, so it does not move the remainder into another row; compare the other routes at the same target.
7. Save, export or print
Three buttons are in the bar at the top of the page (on a phone, under More):
- Import CSV reads a plan saved by the Holding Company Retirement Planner (your name, province, age, the four pool balances, your ACB of the shares, this year’s OAS, CPP, pension and employment income at your age in the plan, and for the Surplus tab your RRSP and TFSA balances and room, your mortgage, and the corporation’s investments, their ACB, its cash and its investment return and mix (growth plus dividend yield as the one return, split into growth, Canadian dividends and foreign income); RRSP/RRIF withdrawals, rental income, interest and capital gains are not copied), the T2 ledger CSV from the holdco tracker (pick a corporation and the latest tax year’s pool balances are applied; if the ledger has an
aaiicolumn, the latest tax year’s investment income of every corporation in the file is added up and fills the Surplus tab’s “Investment income of associated corporations last year”, on the assumption that they are associated with your professional corporation; applied on the Surplus tab, the corporation you pick is left out, because it is the professional corporation itself), the tracker’s CDA ledger (pick a corporation and its running CDA balance is applied), or a scenario you saved with Save (CSV). Columns the tool ignores are reported, not dropped silently. To paste ledger rows from Excel instead, open the import box at the top of the inputs. - Save (CSV) saves the inputs as a CSV file, one field per row, so you can come back to the same scenario. An unknown tax year is refused when you import it.
- Print / Save PDF opens the print dialog, set to landscape; choose "Save as PDF" as the destination.
Under the chart, Export has two more:
- Results (CSV) writes the table as numbers, with disabled routes left empty and their reason in the last column.
- Ledger row (CSV) writes the inputs as one row in the ledger's layout.
8. Know what is not modelled
- Employer health taxes (BC EHT, Ontario EHT, Quebec employer HSF) and payroll remittance timing.
- Corporate rates other than the two the tool uses. The salary deduction uses the combined general rate for your province (federal 15% plus the province’s rate; 27% in BC), or, for the part that comes off small-business income, the federal small-business rate (9%) up to the federal business limit you enter and the province’s small-business rate up to the province’s own limit (worked out from the federal one, or entered separately for Ontario and New Brunswick); that needs the paying corporation’s active business income and business limit (both 0 by default), and it is refused for Quebec. The investment-income reduction of the limit is not computed: you enter the limit after it. Only aggregate investment income (interest, rents, foreign income and taxable capital gains) is taxed at about 50⅔% in BC, of which 30⅔% is refundable; Canadian dividends received are generally not taxed at that rate. If the salary offsets that kind of income, the saving is larger than the general rate, and the refundable part comes back only as the holdco pays taxable dividends, which this tool does not model. If the holdco’s income is only Canadian dividends, there is no taxable income to offset and the deduction has no current benefit, so turn the switch off.
- Other employment income that would share the CPP/EI maximums, and the tax value of the RRSP room a salary creates (the room itself is shown).
- The sale of investments itself: only the capital gain you enter is used, to raise the capital dividend account and the non-eligible RDTOH. The cash from the sale is not worked out for you (the corporation’s estimated tax on the gain is added to every route’s total tax), and the reconstruction of GRIP, CDA or RDTOH from the corporation’s history is not done. The balances are inputs. To compare selling investments for income with other options, inside the holdco or personally, use the Holding Company Retirement Planner.
- Anything about your actual tax return. The tool is a comparison and planning aid.
9. Optional: your own mix, the lowest-tax mix, a sale of investments, and no CPP
Your own mix. The table prices each route on its own. A real plan is usually a mix, and the tax on a mix is not the sum of the rows, because brackets, the basic personal amount, the dividend credit and the OAS clawback all turn on the combined income. Open “Your own mix (optional)”, type an amount for each route you want to use, and the combined result appears under the table. An amount above a balance is an error; it is never moved to another route. The mix is also added as a row to the Results CSV and the JSON export.
Lowest-tax mix. Press “Find the lowest-tax mix” to have the tool search for the mix with the lowest total tax that still delivers your target after-tax cash. It uses your tax-free balances first (loan repayment, capital dividend, PUC up to your ACB), then chooses between eligible and non-eligible dividends. It leaves salary out unless you tick the box, because it cannot value the RRSP room and the CPP/QPP pension a salary buys. The search is a grid, so the answer is close to the lowest tax, not proven to the dollar, and using the tax-free balances now leaves less of them for later years. “Use this mix” copies the answer into “Your own mix” so you can change it.
A sale of investments. If the corporation sells investments to fund the payout, enter the capital gain (sale price less cost). Half of it, the non-taxable half, is added to the capital dividend account, and 30⅔% of the taxable half goes to the non-eligible RDTOH. The corporation’s estimated tax on the gain is added to every route’s corporate tax and total tax, as its own step; it is the same in every route, so it does not change which route costs least, and the average rate and the integration difference leave it out, together with the part of the dividend refund it pays for, so they describe the payout itself. Eligible dividends the corporation receives this year are treated the same way: their Part IV tax is in the total tax, and left out, with the refund it pays for, of the average rate and the integration difference. The tool does not take that tax out of your cash, so enter “Cash available to distribute” after it. Whether and when to sell is a different question: use the Holding Company Retirement Planner for it.
No CPP/QPP. CPP contributions stop at 70 and QPP at 73, and from 65 a worker receiving the pension can elect to stop. Tick “No CPP/QPP is charged on the salary” if that is you; the salary route then charges no CPP/QPP, employee or employer. EI and QPIP are unchanged. The part-year in the year you turn 70 or 73 is not modelled.
10. A sensible way to use the answer
Use the comparison to see the size and direction of the difference between routes, then check the assumptions that matter most for you: your corporate marginal rate, whether the salary deduction has income to offset, your province, and the balances. The tool is deliberately transparent about those assumptions; the answer is only as good as the inputs and the rate table.
Ready to try it? The comparison runs entirely in your browser and needs no sign-up.
Open the comparisonGeneral information for planning and education, not financial, tax or legal advice. Confirm anything you act on with your accountant.