Canada Retirement Planner

Holdco Payout Comparison

For a holding company: the ways to take money out this year (salary, eligible and non-eligible dividends, a capital dividend, a return of paid-up capital, a shareholder loan repaid, or your own mix), side by side with the personal and corporate tax each costs for the after-tax cash you want. It shows the numbers, not a recommendation. How to use it.

For an active corporation, such as a professional corporation: how this year’s surplus, used the same way every year until you retire, compares after tax at retirement: kept in the corporation, paid as salary into your RRSP, or paid as a dividend into your TFSA or onto your mortgage. It shows the numbers, not a recommendation. How it works, the passive income grind and IPPs.

Inputs

click to collapse

Import from the Holding Company Retirement Planner, the T2 ledger or the CDA ledger

Use Import CSV at the top, or paste the rows from Excel below (header row included). Import CSV reads:

  • A plan saved by the Holding Company Retirement Planner (Save Plan): your name, province, age, the four pool balances, your ACB of the shares, this year’s OAS, CPP, pension and other income at your age in the plan, and for the Surplus tab your RRSP and TFSA balances and room, your mortgage, and the corporation’s investments, their ACB, its cash and its investment return and mix.
  • The T2 ledger from the Holdco Tax Pool Tracker: pick a corporation and its latest year’s pool balances, PUC and shareholder loan are applied. If the ledger has an aaii column, the latest year’s investment income of every corporation in the file is added up for the Surplus tab’s “Investment income of associated corporations last year”; applied on the Surplus tab, the corporation you pick is left out (it is the professional corporation itself). Ledger template.
  • The CDA ledger (the tracker’s CDA trades file): pick a corporation and its running capital dividend account balance is applied as the CDA.
  • A scenario you saved here with Save (CSV).

What each use leaves you at retirement

Each use at 100% (what does not fit goes on in your order), and your split. After all tax, with the corporation wound up at retirement (its investments sold and everything paid out as dividends), in today’s dollars.

Use of the surplusAfter tax, today’s dollars After tax, at retirementFrom the corporationRRSP TFSAMortgage savedBehind the highest

If your retirement income is different

The same projections, valued with the tax rates at three retirement incomes (today’s dollars).

Retirement incomeRetainSalary, RRSP Dividend, TFSADividend, mortgageYour split

Breakeven return

The investment return at which keeping the money in the corporation and the best personal use come out even. It takes about a second.

Assumptions to know

From the retirement age on

Year by year, your split

Rows shaded: the reduced limit is below the active income, so part of it is taxed at the general rate.

AgeSurplusCorporate taxSmall-business limit Limit lost to investment income SalaryInto RRSPDividendInto TFSA Mortgage prepaidKept in the corporationCorporation’s investments

Not modelled on the Surplus tab

A planning aid. These are not in the calculation; if one applies to you, ask your accountant.

Take-out amount

$0$500,000

Notices

Routes

Route Gross extraction Personal tax Corporate tax (net of refund) Total tax After-tax cash Average rate Marginal rate Integration difference

Tax against take-out amount

Export:

Selling investments, or already sold some?

Not modelled

click to collapse

A planning aid. These are not in the calculation; if one applies to you, ask your accountant. Details, sources and what has been checked against other tax software: What the comparison does not model.

  • Tax on split income (TOSI, ITA s.120.4); see the TOSI check (optional)
  • Dividends between corporations (s.55(2))
  • Sales of shares to a related corporation (s.84.1)
  • The investment-income grind on the small business limit (s.125(5.1))
  • Corporate tax when the income was earned
  • A loan from the corporation to you (the loan check only warns)
  • Quebec’s own age amount (the other provinces' age amounts are modelled); provincial pension credits are not worked out (enter them in Other provincial non-refundable credits)
  • Corporate income earned this year other than a capital gain or eligible portfolio dividends you enter (no interest, foreign income or non-eligible dividends received)
  • AMT, GIS, instalments, estate planning, IPPs, RCAs and the lifetime capital gains exemption