What the comparison does not model
This is a planning aid. The rules below can change your answer and are not in the calculation. The statements about the Income Tax Act were checked against the Act on the Department of Justice site on 2026-10-21; they are short summaries, not advice. If any of them applies to you, ask your accountant.
Tax rules that can change the answer
- Tax on split income (TOSI), ITA s.120.4. Dividends received by some individuals can be taxed at the highest individual rate (s.120.4(2)), and the dividend tax credit is limited
(s.120.4(3)). This tool taxes dividends at the ordinary graduated rates. It does not test whether an exclusion
applies, such as the “excluded shares” test (10% or more of the votes and of the value, less than
90% of business income from services, not a professional corporation).
The optional TOSI check on the page screens one person you might pay and says whether TOSI is likely; it changes no
figure and is not a ruling.
Source: ITA s.120.4, checked 2026-10-21 - Section 55(2). Some taxable dividends between corporations (those deductible under s.112(1), 112(2) or
138(6)) can be treated as proceeds of disposition or a capital gain instead of a dividend, with the safe-income
rules in s.55(2.1). This tool models dividends paid to an individual only, not dividends between corporations.
Source: ITA s.55(2) and (2.1), checked 2026-10-21 - Section 84.1. When a Canadian-resident individual sells shares to a corporation they do not deal with at
arm’s length, and the corporation becomes connected with the one sold, a dividend can be deemed and the
paid-up capital of the shares issued can be reduced. Not modelled; the return-of-capital route does not apply it.
Source: ITA s.84.1(1), checked 2026-10-21 - The investment-income grind on the small business limit, ITA s.125(5.1). A corporation’s business
limit is reduced by the greater of a taxable-capital reduction and a reduction based on its adjusted aggregate
investment income of the previous year above $50,000 (paragraph (b): the business limit divided by $500,000,
times 5, times the excess over $50,000). The tool does not compute it: you enter the paying corporation’s business
limit after it (a tracker T2 ledger import suggests the limit filed for its latest year). Provinces differ, and the salary step
follows them: most reduce their own limit in the same proportion, so it is worked out from the federal limit you enter
(including the higher PEI, Saskatchewan and Nova Scotia limits); Ontario and New Brunswick do not, and take their own
limit in a separate box. Ontario’s reduction for taxable capital is not computed.
Source: ITA s.125(5.1), checked 2026-10-21; CRA Ontario small business deduction page (modified 2026-04-23) and New Brunswick corporation tax page (modified 2025-05-21), read 2026-10-25
How the comparison is scoped
- It compares withdrawals, not the whole life of the income. It starts from cash already in the holdco, so the corporate tax paid when that income arose is not counted. A dividend route shows only the refund it triggers from the pools you enter, as a negative corporate tax.
- Pools are taken as you enter them. The tool does not build RDTOH, GRIP or CDA up from the year’s income. A sale of investments to fund the payout is taken only as the capital gain you enter: it adds to the capital dividend account and the non-eligible RDTOH, and the corporation’s estimated tax on it is added to every route’s total tax. The cash from the sale is not worked out for you. Eligible portfolio dividends the corporation receives this year are taken only as the amount you enter: the 38⅓% Part IV tax on them is added to the eligible RDTOH and to every route’s total tax, and the dividends to the GRIP. Non-eligible dividends received, dividends from a connected corporation, interest or foreign income earned this year, and the lower Part IV tax when the corporation claims losses (s.186(1)(c) and (d)) are not added.
- Selling investments for income. Whether to sell investments, inside the holdco or personally, to fund your income is a question over many years. The Holding Company Retirement Planner compares those options; this tool compares ways of paying out of the holdco this year.
- Corporate rates. The salary route’s optional corporate deduction (off by default) uses the combined general rate for the selected province (federal 15% plus the province’s rate), or, for the part that comes off small-business income, the combined small-business rate. That needs the two small-business amounts: the paying corporation’s active business income and its business limit (both 0 by default). The deduction comes off income above the business limit first (ITA s.125(1)), worked apart for the federal and the provincial limit. The small-business rate is refused for Quebec, which cuts its deduction for corporations with few remunerated hours.
- Shareholder loans. The table models only the repayment of a loan the corporation owes you. A loan from the corporation to you is not in any figure: the optional Shareholder loan check only warns (ITA s.15(2), s.80.4), changes no number, and does not test employee loans, ordinary-course lending, trusts, non-residents or partnerships.
- Salary. The Canada employment amount (federal) is credited on a salary; employment income typed into Other ordinary income does not get it. The employee CPP is split as the return splits it: the base part earns the credit and the enhanced part is deducted; QPIP rules were not checked; employer health taxes and the value of the RRSP deduction are not modelled; CPP and QPP contributions are charged unless you tick “No CPP/QPP is charged on the salary”, for when CPP has stopped at 70 (QPP at 73) or a worker 65 or older who receives the pension has elected to stop (Forms CPT30 and RR-50-V); the part-year in the year you turn 70 or 73 is not modelled; the employer’s payroll figures are calculated, not externally checked.
- Credits and reductions. The federal age amount and the age amounts of the twelve other provinces and territories are modelled (2026 figures from CRA's TD1 forms). Quebec’s own age amount, which is tested on family income, is not modelled, so a Quebec user 65 or older sees too much Quebec tax. The two retirement planners credit the same provincial age amounts. No provincial pension credit is worked out, in this tool or the planners; in this tool you can enter it, as a dollar amount of credit, in Other provincial non-refundable credits (for you, not for your spouse), and BC’s low-income reduction is off. Ontario’s low-income workers credit (LIFT) is not modelled, so a low Ontario salary can show too much Ontario tax.
- Left out altogether: alternative minimum tax, the guaranteed income supplement, instalments, filing detail, wind-up, pipeline and estate planning, individual pension plans, retirement compensation arrangements, and the lifetime capital gains exemption.
General information for planning and education, not financial, tax or legal advice. Confirm anything you act on with your accountant.